Abuse of Process, Costs Assessment and Privilege: Recent Queensland Court of Appeal Guidance

Russells (A Firm) v Australian Golf Management Corporation Pty Ltd [2026] QCA 78 and Nevgold Pty Ltd v Rostron Carlyle Rojas Lawyers [2026] QCA 244 confirm that abuse of process allegations should not be used to undermine the statutory costs assessment regime. Both decisions emphasise that a client exercising rights under the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) will not ordinarily be engaging in an abuse of process.
In Russells (A Firm), a law firm argued that a client's costs assessment application was an abuse of process and that privilege had been waived. Bradley JA rejected those arguments, holding that a client does not lose legal professional privilege merely by challenging legal costs, disclosure obligations or the quality of legal services. The statutory right to seek review of legal costs can be exercised without placing privileged communications in issue.
The decision also rejected an attempt to rely on abuse of process allegations to access privileged material. The fact that a party alleges abuse of process does not, of itself, displace legal professional privilege. A proper evidentiary foundation is required before privilege can be disturbed.
In Nevgold Pty Ltd, a costs assessment application was dismissed at first instance on abuse of process grounds. Crow J found that the allegation had not been clearly raised and that the applicant had not been given a fair opportunity to respond. Serious allegations of abuse of process must be properly pleaded and fairly litigated before they can justify the dismissal of proceedings.
The judgment further recognised that seeking a statutory assessment of legal costs is the very purpose for which the legislative scheme exists. Even where there is hostility between solicitor and client, or collateral disputes surrounding the retainer, the pursuit of a costs assessment will not ordinarily constitute an abuse of process.
Taken together, these authorities demonstrate that abuse of process remains a narrow doctrine in solicitor-client costs disputes. The courts will require clear evidence that a proceeding is being used for a purpose foreign to its legitimate function before intervening. Mere reliance upon statutory costs remedies, or the assertion of legal professional privilege, will not satisfy that threshold
Comments